|
11:59 am
|
Marisa_C:
|
On your marks? for another #ELTchat?
|
|
12:00 pm
|
teachermedeiros:
|
I use to focus on intonation and pronunciation. So, I do believe that what I've been teaching is fully relevant ;) #ELTChat
|
|
12:00 pm
|
sanmccarron:
|
RT @barbsaka: RT @Marisa_C: @vladkaslniecko #eltchat Is what you?re teaching relevant to what your students need? If not, Who/ what to blame?
|
|
12:01 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
OK, question: who still teaches five-paragraph essays? #ELTchat
|
|
12:01 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
I guess my first question to everyone is what do you mean by "relevant"? #eltchat
|
|
12:01 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @barbsaka: I guess my first question to everyone is what do you mean by "relevant"? #eltchat
|
|
12:02 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@barbsaka Yes, relevance in terms of content, skills, goals, learning styles, etc... #ELTChat
|
|
12:02 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
RT @englishraven: @barbsaka Yes, relevance in terms of content, skills, goals, learning styles, etc... #ELTChat
|
|
12:02 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@barbsaka gd question - it can extend to many things from context to English they will use and so on #eltchat
|
|
12:02 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@barbsaka When suggesting this topic I was thinking in terms of 'relevant to future needs #ELTchat
|
|
12:02 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
RT @barbsaka: I guess my first question to everyone is what do you mean by "relevant"? #eltchat ] what learners need/want to learn, I'd say
|
|
12:03 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @yearinthelifeof: @barbsaka When suggesting this topic I was thinking in terms of 'relevant to future needs #ELTchat
|
|
12:03 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@yearinthelifeof : I do! Spaniards aren't taught to write in school and most like having a formula to work with... #eltchat
|
|
12:03 pm
|
englishraven:
|
Adding to @barbsaka 's first question, I would ask who is deciding what is relevant/needed? #ELTChat
|
|
12:03 pm
|
BethCagnol:
|
As for the blame bit, I'm going to jump right in and say: TESTS are to blame. There, I said it. #ELTChat
|
|
12:03 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @yearinthelifeof: @barbsaka When suggesting this topic I was thinking in terms of 'relevant to future needs #ELTchat
|
|
12:03 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@bethcagnol Surprise, surprise :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:03 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
@barbsaka: I guess my first question is what do you mean by "relevant"? > what will help ss to use Eng effectively in own lives #eltchat
|
|
12:04 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @BethCagnol: As for the blame bit, I'm going to jump right in and say: TESTS are to blame. There, I said it. #ELTChat
|
|
12:04 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
#ELTchat - mots often relevant is decided far far away from the real classroom situation
|
|
12:04 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@barbsaka I would say relevant is = what stds need (as well as what they want) to learn (...can be different sometimes :-))) #eltchat
|
|
12:04 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@barbsaka : "Relevant" - how can you use English in your life? If lx is a tool, what do you want to be able to do? #eltchat
|
|
12:04 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@esolcourses @barbsaka They might not know what they need, which can be quite different to what they want, anyway #ELTchat
|
|
12:04 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @JoshSRound: @barbsaka: I guess my first question is what do you mean by "relevant"? > what will help ss to use Eng effectively in own lives #eltchat
|
|
12:04 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
RT @bethcagnol: As for the blame bit, I'm going to jump right in and say: TESTS are to blame. There, I said it. #ELTChat ] seconded
|
|
12:04 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
What is the usual way you assess your students' needs? #ELTchat Do you do this?
|
|
12:04 pm
|
edumazing:
|
We need to ensure relevance to current needs before applying it to future needs #eltchat
|
|
12:04 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
So some teachers think relevant is what students identify as goals, and some think it is what teachers see that students need #eltchat
|
|
12:04 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @bethcagnol: As for the blame bit, I'm going to jump right in TESTS are to blame. There, I said it. #ELTChat well tests and schools
|
|
12:04 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@englishraven @barbsaka : Adult students need to bear some responsibility for what/why they learn... #eltchat
|
|
12:04 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@bethcagnol I would disagree slightly. Tests aren't always bad. What they're used for and how are! #ELTchat
|
|
12:04 pm
|
Collaborative:
|
#eltchat Job application & CV relevant is relevant, Lack of targets is to blame and over-emphasis on mere processing/pedaling
|
|
12:05 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
#ELTchat - most often 'relevant' is pre-fixed & teachers end up teaching wt's in the text - 'cover' syllabus
|
|
12:05 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@bethcagnol I agree to an extent. Also, using a coursebook as a crutch because eaier than preparing a course that meets needs #ELTchat
|
|
12:05 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @stopspanglish: @englishraven @barbsaka : Adult students need to bear some responsibility for what/why they learn... #eltchat <definitely
|
|
12:05 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @edumazing: We need to ensure relevance to current needs before applying it to future needs #eltchat Thats a good point
|
|
12:05 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@barbsaka @stopspanglish I think there's an important interface/meeting point there that needs to considered. Often isn't. #ELTChat
|
|
12:05 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
That's another one--revelant to the assigned course goals (like not getting off track). Slippery word, relevant :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:05 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @cherrymp: #ELTchat 'relevant' is often pre-fixed & teachers end up teaching wt's in the text - 'cover' syllabus <at least til confident
|
|
12:06 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@Marisa_C #ELTchat difficult to access - can use placement tests - bt stdised tests may not be available to all
|
|
12:06 pm
|
edumazing:
|
I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:06 pm
|
BethCagnol:
|
@englishraven And how they are poorly designed Nd thought out is also to blame. #ELTChat
|
|
12:06 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
@barbsaka 'Relevant' - can the students take what they learn in your classroom and apply it in their lives? #eltchat
|
|
12:06 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
If a S calls me and says, "I want to learn English for my job" but can't explain why... I don't take that student on. #eltchat
|
|
12:06 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
@yearinthelifeof @barbsaka agreed... think there has to be an element of negotiated learning (their wishes + prof. guidance) #ELTChat
|
|
12:06 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:06 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
#eltchat relevant feedback is key to a successful learning. What do you think?
|
|
12:06 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
RT @barbsaka: Thats another one--revelant to the assigned course goals . Slippery word, relevant :-) >>Indeed!! #eltchat
|
|
12:06 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
Cool! RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:06 pm
|
rissL:
|
RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:06 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@Marisa_C Conduct research into how they will be using English in their academic lives - I'm lucky - access to data / longtimeframe #ELTchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @BrunoELT: #eltchat relevant feedback is key to a successful learning. What do you think? <definitely a part of it
|
|
12:07 pm
|
mickstout:
|
I think often need 4 Eng in Jp only comes up in emergency. #ELTchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
RT @barbsaka: Cool! RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@edumazing I like your three Rs (relevant, rich, real)! #ELTChat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
often YLs need to be trained (very slowly) to identify their needs, which shd be a part of the course content (learner training) #eltchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@stopspanglish dont u try & help them see what they want? Half the time I find they don't actually know quite what they want /need #eltchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
RT @englishraven: @edumazing I like your three Rs (relevant, rich, real)! #ELTChat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
@englishraven @barbsaka Surely the students determine what is relevant to their needs? #eltchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
Think delivering what learners need is ultimately down to teachers, but teachers rarely get full say in deciding what to teach #ELTChat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@edumazing real is more important - how students can relate to the content #ELTchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
IMHO learning English is like dieting. If you don't have clear motivation, you're not gonna get far. #eltchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
NikkiFortova:
|
RT @teacher_prix: RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @englishraven: @edumazing I like your three Rs (relevant, rich, real)! #ELTChat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
Wow! RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
GailDesler:
|
RT @barbsaka: Cool! RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @esolcourses: Think delivering what learners need is ultimately down to teachers, but teachers rarely get full say in deciding what to teach #ELTChat
|
|
12:07 pm
|
sedayyildirim:
|
I blame the Ministry of Education here in Turkey ! #eltchat
|
|
12:08 pm
|
Collaborative:
|
#eltchat Targets > Job application, CV > EU Language Passport http://ht.ly/4kBNh
|
|
12:08 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
Wow! ?? RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:08 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: @stopspanglish Half the time I find they don't know quite what they want /need #eltchat <i agree! +changes all the time
|
|
12:08 pm
|
BethCagnol:
|
Sometimes I get caught up in prepping sts for the next school year rather than life in English itself. #ELTChat
|
|
12:08 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@sandymillin @BrunoELT yeah true - feedback needs to be constructive #ELTchat
|
|
12:08 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
@edumazing: I like that idea, but when you have to cover pre-determined syllabus, how do you put all that together? #eltchat
|
|
12:08 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
RT @sedayyildirim: I blame the Ministry of Education here in Turkey ! #eltchat > that's as high as you can blame! :-D
|
|
12:08 pm
|
mickstout:
|
Firefighters and rescue workers don't feel a need until forced 2 deal w/ foreign aid wrkrs. #ELTchat
|
|
12:08 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
RT @esolcourses: Think delivering what learners need is ultimately down to teachers, but teachers rarely get full say in deciding what to teach #ELTChat
|
|
12:08 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @edumazing: Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat I like those Rs :-)
|
|
12:08 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@worldteacher In a perfect world perhaps. Also need to consider situation of younger learners, who can't always judge as well. #ELTChat
|
|
12:08 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@esolcourses I agree that it's down to teachers, but not all teachers confident in determining what SS need either #ELTChat
|
|
12:08 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@teacher_prix @edumazing what if they will need it - but it's not connected to their lives at present? #ELTchat
|
|
12:08 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@esolcourses true - that happens across regions #ELTchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@BrunoELT @edumazing On what basis to you decide the 3Rs? Genuinely interested #ELTchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
teachers are often put under pressure to get s's to pass exams, but syllabus may not be relevant to what learners want or need #ELTChat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
I think Richard's ideas on adapting the textbook are relevant to meeting student's needs. http://bit.ly/f6FeXc #eltchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @ddeubel: I think Richard's ideas on adapting the textbook are relevant to meeting student's needs. http://bit.ly/f6FeXc #eltchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@worldteacher I don't think it's necessarily the case in all classes. Ss don't have tradition of choice #eltchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
So true! ? RT @stopspanglish: IMHO learning English is like dieting. If you don't have clear motivation, you're not gonna get far. #eltchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
@englishraven @esolcourses Agree, teachers often given course book to use and get on with covering units #eltchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@Shaunwilden : Of course. But if they just want English to keep their jobs, for example, that's not something my thing. #eltchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
Collaborative:
|
#eltchat Targets > EU Language Levels > Job application, CV > Self Assessment Grid http://ht.ly/4kBQg
|
|
12:09 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
RT @ddeubel: I think Richard's ideas on adapting the textbook are relevant to meeting student's needs. http://bit.ly/f6FeXc #eltchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
edumazing:
|
@englishraven Thanks. I use them when working with educators and preservice teachers to change old paradigms #eltchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
RT @yearinthelifeof: @BrunoELT @edumazing On what basis to you decide the 3Rs? >> How best to determine needs on a weekly basis? #eltchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@Marisa_C @sedayyildirim can be minister - don't know whether s/he is hr or not - in some cases ministry gets equated to person #ELTchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@teacher_prix This is a lot of the problem isnt it- the syallbus is designed by sb who doesnt actually know the sts #eltchat
|
|
12:09 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@Shaunwilden Agree that YL's not in a position to identify needs - that's why this age grp needs EXPERT Ts not the least qualified #ELTchat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @Marisa_C: @Shaunwilden Agree that YL's not in a position to identify needs - that's why this age grp needs EXPERT Ts not the least qualified #ELTchat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@Marisa_C @sedayyildirim YÖK (Turkish educ. ministry) do more damage than any other stakeholder here in Turkey #ELTchat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@mickstout Good real-life examples every day, now :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
RT @edumazing I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat Great!!
|
|
12:10 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@Shaunwilden : "I can show you the door, Neo. But YOU have to walk through it." #eltchat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: @teacher_prix This is a lot of the problem isnt it- the syallbus is designed by sb who doesnt actually know the sts #eltchat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: @teacher_prix ...problem - the syallbus is designed by sb who doesnt actually know the sts #eltchat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @stopspanglish: IMHO learning English is like dieting. If you don't have clear motivation, u're not gonna get far. #eltchat - So true! =)
|
|
12:10 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@ddeubel that's really where teacher can really contribute - making content real and immediate to students' exp #ELTchat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
@sandymillin agree. When I first started teaching, I sometimes let outside infl. cloud my judgement.. experience helps a lot, IMO #ELTChat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
RT @barbsaka: RT @ddeubel: I think Richard's ideas on adapting the textbook are relevant to meeting student's needs. http://bit.ly/f6FeXc #eltchat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
How many teachers get the support / time to do a proper needs analysis? #eltchat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
#eltchat And how often do you reassess syllabus? Ours are made at start of year - not necessarily relevant to SS, esp. for exam prep
|
|
12:10 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
If students have to take an exam, then isn't preparation to help them succeed relevant (even if not their interest?) #eltchat
|
|
12:10 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
#eltchat Talking abt relevance what do u think is totally irrelevant in EFL classes? We seem to turn a blind eye on that and not discuss it
|
|
12:10 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
RT @ddeubel: How many teachers get the support / time to do a proper needs analysis? #eltchat> not that often
|
|
12:11 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@bethcagnol Ask them what they think they need and whether your teaching is relevant :-) #ELTChat
|
|
12:11 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
RT @Marisa_C: @Shaunwilden Agree that YL's not in a position to identify needs - that's why this age grp needs EXPERT Ts not the least qualified #ELTchat
|
|
12:11 pm
|
tearoof:
|
RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:11 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@esolcourses Definitely - I'm getting better and better (I hope!) at assessing needs, especially as I'm inspired through Twitter #ELTChat
|
|
12:11 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@Shaunwilden @teacher_prix bt wt to do - teachers can adapt to the text to the level of the students' needs rt? #ELTchat
|
|
12:11 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @barbsaka: If students have to take an exam, then isn't preparation to help them succeed relevant (even if not their interest?) #eltchat
|
|
12:11 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
RT @BrunoELT: #eltchat What do u think is totally irrelevant in EFL classes? We seem to turn a blind eye on that and not discuss it
|
|
12:11 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
But I think it would be a good idea to put TEACHERS in there in your equations - so far it's all about content & perhaps method - #Eltchat
|
|
12:11 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@stopspanglish 5 parag essay - Does it have any relevance down the line? Less than 1% of uni profs ever ask studs to write 5par ess #ELTchat
|
|
12:11 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
And teachers should know, and be honest about, where their expertise lies - if you don't like teaching YLs, be honest about it. #eltchat
|
|
12:11 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@cherrymp Agreed but if the syllabus say you must cover this then teachers often feel they can't #eltchat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
What kind of teachers do our learners need? #Eltchat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
edumazing:
|
Teachers should be leading students to discover what is relevant. They need the guidance as at times it isn't obvious to them #eltchat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
#ELTchat @ddeubel needs analysis is a continuous process - at every lesson, maybe
|
|
12:12 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@barbsaka true - bt how long can 1 teach sb who's not interested - that's where teachers need to go beyond #ELTchat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
@waykatewit @edumazing They probably will, but the way it's put together could make more sense in a way to interest + involve them #ELTchat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@BrunoELT I don't think anything is irrelevant by design. I think it's relevant or irrelevant in how teacher approaches it #eltchat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@barbsaka Yes, think if motivation in studying English is primarily to score well on certain tests, that has to be a relevant need. #ELTChat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
Rare moments ?RT @Marisa_C: RT @ddeubel: How many teachers get the support / time to do a proper needs analysis? #eltchat> not that often
|
|
12:12 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@ddeubel needs analysis is only any good if it's reviewed regularly AND acted upon. Support - training #eltchat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@Marisa_C Important part of the question - Who is to blame? Are teachers for not contributing more? #ELTchat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
sedayyildirim:
|
@yearinthelifeof @Marisa_C unfortunately they damage and also they force us to do so ! #eltchat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@ddeubel Not many, especially with syllabus / coursebook- 1 lesson = 2 pages! ...#eltchat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @Marisa_C: What kind of teachers do our learners need? #Eltchat In the Czech rep the answer would be the ones that charge least ;-)
|
|
12:12 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
@englishraven Agreed - YLs have to be handled differently, but, with adults, my most useful lesson is the 1st one - needs analysis. #eltchat
|
|
12:12 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@yearinthelifeof : Yes, because it teaches them that organizing and preparing a text makes writing a lot easier to do. #eltchat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@sandymillin not very often - in india depends on states - not uniform #ELTchat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@BrunoELT A good teacher can find a way to make anything relevant IMHO #eltchat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@barbsaka @BrunoELT I personally find may of the coursebook vovabulary clusters irrelevant #ELTchat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@ddeubel ...but difficult to change when sharing classes or w/ continuing classes / different teachers each year #eltchat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
RT @ddeubel: How many teachers get the support / time to do a proper needs analysis? #eltchat ] may be wrong, but not many, I imagine...
|
|
12:13 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
Often the trouble is that Course books broadly hit the mark for 'most' ss, teachers can fall into the trap of relying on that #eltchat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@Shaunwilden but so true of so many contexts... #Eltchat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: 'syallbus designed by sb who doesnt actually know the sts' - been suffereing from this 'illness' here!!! #eltchat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@worldteacher Totally agree with you on that one. Surprises me, though, how often adults struggle to define what they 'want/need'. #ELTChat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@BrunoELT Think it depends on students - talking about animal names probably irrelevant to CEO of major international company ;) #eltchat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@Marisa_C motivating - challenging to make them think beyond the box #ELTchat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
@bcnpaul1 Agree - that's why we need to focus more on the enacted curriculum and see curriculum less "set" and more "fluid". #eltchat
|
|
12:13 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
@barbsaka You have a point there! Relevance comes from what teachers decide to work on #ELTchat
|
|
12:14 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@waykatewit Because the coursebook vocabulary doesn't relate to students interests or daily life? #eltchat
|
|
12:14 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
I know I've mentioned this in previous chats, but I think teaching study skills in the ESL classroom is fundamental. #eltchat
|
|
12:14 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@yearinthelifeof @Marisa_C Teachers feel comfortable placingthe responsibility on the coursebook -" I'm told to teach it" stuff #ELTchat
|
|
12:14 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @edumazing: Teachers should be leading students to discover what is relevant. They need the guidance as at times it isn't obvious to them #eltchat
|
|
12:14 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@Shaunwilden i guess u ddn't miss the pun in 'cover' - in the hurry to cover the joy of learning is lost #ELTchat
|
|
12:14 pm
|
edumazing:
|
@cherrymp They are actually all important. Something can be real but lack no meaning if it isn't relevant 2 actual students #eltchat
|
|
12:14 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@stopspanglish Organizing writing is important but research suggests skills not transferable to other writing genres :-( #ELTchat
|
|
12:14 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@BrunoELT A good teacher can find a way to make anything relevant IMHO #eltchat Well almst anything & if they can't then dont teach it
|
|
12:14 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@OUPELTGlobal @esolcourses yes, sensible and also flexible and responsbile >> teacher #eltchat
|
|
12:15 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @cherrymp: @Shaunwilden i guess u ddn't miss the pun in 'cover' - in the hurry to cover the joy of learning is lost #ELTchat So true
|
|
12:15 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
RT @barbsaka If students have to take an exam, then isn't preparation to help them succeed relevant? #eltchat Absolutely!!
|
|
12:15 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@yearinthelifeof Do you have a link to some of that research? (on writing being non-tranferable skill)? #eltchat
|
|
12:15 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @bcnpaul1: @ddeubel needs analysis is only any good if it's reviewed regularly AND acted upon. Support - training #eltchat > definitely
|
|
12:15 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@ddeubel @bcnpaul1 that's an interesting point - fluid and set curriculum #ELTchat
|
|
12:15 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@Shaunwilden But that's very true. For many learners/contexts, cheapest provider is everything. #ELTChat
|
|
12:15 pm
|
Collaborative:
|
#eltchat Targets > Needs > People Capability Maturity Model P-CMM http://ht.ly/4kC3b
|
|
12:15 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
@sandymillin perhaps is more difficult to define relevance when dealing with sts of mixed levels or abilities/goals in class #ELTchat
|
|
12:15 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@barbsaka irrelevant for life. As fore personal interest - I can always inspire them, I think #ELTchat
|
|
12:15 pm
|
edumazing:
|
@teacher_prix Pre-determined syllabus doesn't work as all student experiences are different #eltchat
|
|
12:15 pm
|
mickstout:
|
@Barb, Yes, now Jp authorities looking 4 interpreters cuz JP rescue workers can't communicate w/ frgn recue wrkrs. But who knew?! #ELTchat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
RT @stopspanglish: I know I've mentioned this in previous chats, but I think teaching study skills in the ESL classroom is fundamental. #eltchat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@yearinthelifeof Disagree. That totally depends on how advanced your students' writing skills are to start with. #eltchat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@Shaunwilden Think that's the case in many places! (charge less - no regard for quality if they don't know about the business) #Eltchat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
@ddeubel IME, the expectation is that teachers will do a needs analysis, but it's a very time-consuming process to do properly #ELTChat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
I also think that school staff need to meet together more often to discuss students and their needs. It is collaborative. #eltchat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
RT @ddeubel: that's why we need to focus more on the enacted curriculum and see curriculum less "set" and more "fluid". #eltchat >yes
|
|
12:16 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
RT @stopspanglish: I know I've mentioned this in previous chats, but I think teaching study skills in the ESL classroom is fundamental. #eltchat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@waykatewit That would be an interesting challenge, to try and tweak irrelevant vocab to make it more meaningful :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@barbsaka Somewhere, will hunt it down after this session - v. eye opening and will change your mind about 5 parag essays #ELTchat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@edumazing mmm - esp my students for whom #english is still a fl - dey need to u's ways of using wt dey learn in meaningful ways #ELTchat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
@englishraven Yes, many adult students need lots of guidance through the needs analysis process! #eltchat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
RT @bcnpaul1: RT @ddeubel: <snip> we need to focus more on the enacted curriculum and see curriculum less "set" & more "fluid". #eltchat
|
|
12:16 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
@cherrymp @Shaunwilden We can always adapt, but them we have sts + parents say: the T isn't using ALL the pages of the book! #ELTchat
|
|
12:17 pm
|
edumazing:
|
@waykatewit Then we support them 2 find the connection. Scaffold learning. #eltchat
|
|
12:17 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@ddeubel I agree that curriculum should be more fluid - but what about inexperienced teachers? Could that be detrimental to thm/SS #eltchat
|
|
12:17 pm
|
mickstout:
|
@Shaunwilden Hmmm, guess I better find another job. #ELTchat. Not always possible 2 make Eng relevant in Jp.
|
|
12:17 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
We cannot assume that Ss are receiving quality academic support at home or at school. #eltchat
|
|
12:17 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
@mubeenfk - YES. Local content is what is also needed. CSC. Culturally specific content. #eltchat
|
|
12:17 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
#eltchat Maybe we shld ask our sts whether what we consider relevant is truly relevant for their life or if we are taking things 4 granted
|
|
12:17 pm
|
sedayyildirim:
|
@Shaunwilden @Marisa_C learners need teachers that balance compulsory relevant & irrelevant items both #eltchat
|
|
12:17 pm
|
mubeenfk:
|
@ddeubel completely agree with you... they need to be fluid. Localisation is so important in EFL #eltchat
|
|
12:17 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @ddeubel: I also think that school staff need to meet together more often to discuss sts and their needs. It is collaborative #ELTchat
|
|
12:17 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
#ELTchat @worldteacher @barbsaka it's a question of whether exams are relevant! :)
|
|
12:17 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@ddeubel true - bt v often teaching is a lonely profession rt? #ELTchat
|
|
12:17 pm
|
azangolszekely:
|
#eltchat coursebook are a useful teaching crutch but they are hardly ever relevant to the pupils in any classroom
|
|
12:18 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
@esolcourses Sue. NA is time consuming but not necessarily so if you can get the students doing some of that work. #eltchat
|
|
12:18 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@Shaunwilden I why I talked about expert Ts for YL's - in Greece they throw the youngest/least qualified/cheapest Ts in with YL's #ELTchat
|
|
12:18 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
#ELTchat @barbsaka making the meaningless meaningful - I see it as part of our job/role :)
|
|
12:18 pm
|
yitzha_sarwono:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: @BrunoELT A good teacher can find a way to make anything relevant IMHO #eltchat Well almst anything & if they can't then dont teach it
|
|
12:18 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
What abt the part tutorials can play in identifying learner needs? - Indiv Learning Plans anyone? #eltchat
|
|
12:18 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@stopspanglish Agree in part, but are you teaching writing or just the vocab of writing (linkers/transitions) v. different #ELTchat
|
|
12:18 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@teacher_prix @Shaunwilden yeah true - dat's where d teachers need to win trust - suddenly teaching is not jst teaching #ELTchat
|
|
12:18 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
I meant as in dont cover that material if it is not relevant e.g. some books cover pron not relvant to your sts so why do it? #eltchat
|
|
12:18 pm
|
sherrattsam:
|
RT @barbsaka: So some teachers think relevant is what students identify as goals, and some think it is what teachers see that students need #eltchat
|
|
12:18 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
RT @JoshSRound: What abt the part tutorials can play in identifying learner needs? - Indiv Learning Plans anyone? #eltchat> A v good idea
|
|
12:18 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@BrunoELT oh yes! communication with students is absolutely ESSENTIAL! We should built on that #eltchat
|
|
12:18 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
@cherrymp sad but true. But I wish staff would plan together and make this common practice. #eltchat
|
|
12:18 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @edumazing Pre-determined syllabus doesn't work as all student experiences are different #eltchat - So true!
|
|
12:19 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@barbsaka Like too many things, the formula was created to make it teachable / testable #ELTchat
|
|
12:19 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
@ddeubel agree & I often do... problem tho is often not the needs analysis, as the time involved in writing it up afterwards! #ELTChat
|
|
12:19 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@mubeenfk @ddeubel So true! Tired of the Mc Donalds - style coursebooks... :( #ELTchat
|
|
12:19 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: @teacher_prix I know, I used to have that 'fight' all the time when was DoS - parents need training as well as sts #ELTchat
|
|
12:19 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
class size is sth where many teachers won't have a say - that too affects how things are taught or learned #ELTchat
|
|
12:19 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@teacher_prix That's why you always open to every page, even if you don't do much on it :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:19 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@yearinthelifeof Both. And more. I teach business learners, and a business learner who cannot write is TOAST. #eltchat
|
|
12:19 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
RT @waykatewit: #ELTchat @barbsaka making the meaningless meaningful - I see it as part of our job/role :)
|
|
12:19 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@JoshSRound Tutorials need to be structured in some way - that's what we have found - otherwise turn into aimless chats #eltchat
|
|
12:19 pm
|
yitzha_sarwono:
|
Teachers that are needed here are the ones who can answer all students' questions! Fail one and they find it hard to trust you #eltchat
|
|
12:20 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@Marisa_C We introduced tutorials twice a year with sts, in my exp they worked as sts got the chance to ask and get gd 121 advice #eltchat
|
|
12:20 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
RT @barbsaka the very first class I ever taught (English as L1) was the 5 p essay for high school seniors who needed it to graduate #ELTchat
|
|
12:20 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@mickstout "English for no apparent reason" (I've taught that class!) #eltchat
|
|
12:20 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@BrunoELT Maybe we should also back ourselves as Ts and not always take Ss' perceived needs as the best/only indicator. #ELTChat
|
|
12:20 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
pre-determined syllabus is a starting point - what u do with it is the most important thing & student involvement in its evolutiion #eltchat
|
|
12:20 pm
|
mickstout:
|
@Marisa_C In Jp. Eng will be intro'd in primary school soon. HR Tt mostly can't speak Eng. ALTs aren't trained tt. #Eltchat
|
|
12:20 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@yitzha_sarwono mmm - i can relate to wt u said - teacher is sb who's al d ans #ELTchat
|
|
12:20 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
#eltchat most of EFL teachers fail to promote modes of meaning-making processes for the students. Don't you agree?
|
|
12:20 pm
|
edumazing:
|
@yearinthelifeof The 3Rs are guided by students. Providing Inquiry learning opportunities supports learners 2 discover connections #eltchat
|
|
12:20 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@yearinthelifeof teachable, testable, and oh, so, very, boring :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:21 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
RT @englishraven:Maybe we should also back ourselves as Ts and not always take Ss' perceived needs as best/only indicator. #ELTChat >agree
|
|
12:21 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
@Marisa_C Yes, we have a 'template' for tutorials; the challenge is to ensure info on needs then gets to relevants Ts to 'act on'.. #eltchat
|
|
12:21 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@englishraven @BrunoELT that's an interesting pt #ELTchat
|
|
12:21 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@harrisonmike #eltchat Is what you?re teaching relevant to what your students need? If not, Who/ what to blame?
|
|
12:21 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@mickstout that sounds like a pretty dire situation #Eltchat
|
|
12:21 pm
|
BlackCatCideb:
|
RT @teachingenglish: ideas for setting homework for young learners. http://bit.ly/h6vDor #teachingenglish #britishcouncil #TESOL #eltchat #efl #esl
|
|
12:21 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
@ddeubel IME, teachers often find themselves tied to working within rigid, inflexible systems with little scope for deviation #ELTChat
|
|
12:21 pm
|
cintiastella:
|
Ss see us as role models so our attitude determines in a great way whether sth is meaningful or not #eltchat
|
|
12:21 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@englishraven @BrunoELT Absolutely! Too often students are not sure ab. what they need/their + needs change #ELTchat
|
|
12:21 pm
|
englishraven:
|
How many of you have taught lessons on ordering food to Ss who will probably never have to order food in English? :-) #ELTChat
|
|
12:22 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@bcnpaul1 true - teachers r to b equipped to innovate and adapt #ELTchat
|
|
12:22 pm
|
mickstout:
|
@barbsaka I often teach that class :-( and it's not always the admin's fault. Often sts CHOOSE a course that isn't relevant. #ELTchat
|
|
12:22 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
What should be included in a 'needs analysis'? Do you believe this is the best way to raise sts' needs? #ELTChat
|
|
12:22 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@JoshSRound I think the 'template' could also include a 'progress' stocktaking character and then a goal defining section #eltchat
|
|
12:22 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @JoshSRound: What abt the part tutorials can play in identifying learner needs? - Indiv Learning Plans anyone? #eltchat
|
|
12:22 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
Can students plan the curriculum? They do many times have a lot of experience with curriculum.... #eltchat
|
|
12:22 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
RT @teacher_prix: What should be included in a 'needs analysis'? Do you believe this is the best way to raise sts' needs? #ELTChat
|
|
12:22 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
@englishraven but surely their impressions and ideas must be taken into account as well and then we build knowledge in conjunction #ELTchat
|
|
12:22 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
@englishraven - or maybe it's a matter of striking a balance between what learners think they need & Ts know they need? #eltchat
|
|
12:22 pm
|
Collaborative:
|
#eltchat Training needs analysis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Training_needs_analysis
|
|
12:22 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@Marisa_C @JoshSRound mm - bt d small size is sth that teachers can explore and exploit for students' adv #ELTchat
|
|
12:22 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @chucksandy: @englishraven - or maybe it's a matter of striking a balance between what learners think they need & Ts know they need? #eltchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
@Marisa_C @Shaunwilden also need to have a range of tutorials - at start of course, then with regular follow-ups to monitor goals #eltchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
edumazing:
|
The real world does not have exams. It has experiences that our students need to learn from and be part of . Edn not consistent #eltchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
RT @teacher_prix: What should be included in a 'needs analysis'? Do you believe this is the best way to raise sts' needs? #ELTChat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
BigWorldBgTeach:
|
RT @edumazing: I use the 3Rs in my work - Relevant-connected 2 student, Rich-deep in content, Real - related to their world #eltchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@JoshSRound agree #eltchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@Shaunwilden @Marisa_C I have tutorials on a weekly basis - huge part of building a relationship with ss around what they need #ELTchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
#ELTchat @englishraven I did! :)) they loved it, though :) #ELTchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
@sandymillin RT How often do you reassess syllabus? #eltchat It's a continuous process except for exam courses, but even those are 'tweaked'
|
|
12:23 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
RT @JoshSRound: What abt the part tutorials can play in identifying learner needs? - Indiv Learning Plans anyone? #eltchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
mickstout:
|
@Shaunwilden Right. Of course, unless you're forced to do it. In my case I seldom have alone looking over my shoulder :-) #ELTchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
harrisonmike:
|
Always think a bit about previous experience and studies is useful, for English language learning and in general #eltchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@englishraven i've - it's funny - esp in #myanmar ath in #english is quite distant to many of my students #ELTchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
question: when you teach same course & same book the nxt year - do you do it the same or different? #eltchat >i'd say different for most ppl
|
|
12:23 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@JoshSRound : Three cheers for individual learning plans!! #eltchat
|
|
12:23 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@yearinthelifeof every week seems a bit excessive - but OK if doing an intensive course #ELTchat
|
|
12:24 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@Shaunwilden In Asia, if it's in the book, it's relevant! (Me from Calif. has taught British English pronunciation) #eltchat
|
|
12:24 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @JoshSRound: @Marisa_C @Shaunwilden also need to have a range of tutorials - at start of course, then with regular follow-ups to monitor goals #eltchat
|
|
12:24 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@englishraven Yep! That's why I really try to adapt the content of the coursebooks I teach from #eltchat >>use same gram in diff context
|
|
12:24 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
RT @azangolszekely: #eltchat coursebooks... are hardly ever relevant... >agreed, but few teachers have time to prepare lessons without one
|
|
12:24 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@BrunoELT @chucksandy I think that's a really important priority: balance (Ss and T working together on the needs and relevance). #ELTChat
|
|
12:24 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
RT @bcnpaul1: question: when you teach same course & same book the nxt year - do you do it the same or different? #eltchat > different!
|
|
12:24 pm
|
theminddock:
|
#eltchat Training needs analysis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Training_needs_analysis
|
|
12:24 pm
|
yitzha_sarwono:
|
@cherrymp the good things is they look up to you ,the down side is they expect you to be perfect #eltchat
|
|
12:24 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@marisa_c tweetgrid didn't work but hootsuite's holding up so far :) #eltchat
|
|
12:24 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@barbsaka @stopspanglish Where I work no professors ask them to write 5 parag essays - writing normally is 'define 'x' in 100 words #ELTchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@grahamstanley @azangolszekely ...or they HAVE TO use the course books :-(( #eltchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
RT @stopspanglish: Three cheers for individual learning plans!! - are you a fan? :)) any tips? #eltchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
#ELTchat @stopspanglish @JoshSRound How about the management then? overwhelming... ?
|
|
12:25 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
Have you ever asked your Ss to choose their coursebook? I have done it and it works really well #ELTchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
RT @azangolszekely: "coursebooks... are hardly ever relevant..." That's sad to hear. What do you do with them then? #eltchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@esolcourses @bcnpaul1 It's never the same between classes or from year to year #eltchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@bcnpaul1 interesting qn - i adapt and try to do sth different - keep wt went ok discard wt went wrong - fill d gaps #ELTchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
RT @englishraven: @BrunoELT @chucksandy I think that's a really important priority: balance (Ss and T working together on the needs and relevance). #ELTChat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
mickstout:
|
@Marisa_C It is! Some HR Tt are Gr8. They model good language learning, but others...It'll be while till most Jp speak English :-( #ELTchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
cybraryman1:
|
WedChat:#ClavEd #ELTchat #ntchat #ptchat #ecosys#PHDchat#edmusichat#SGAchat #web20chat #DistEd#smchat#yalitchat#FYCchat:http://bit.ly/9bCqR
|
|
12:25 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@JoshSRound Who does the tutorials? Sounds like it's not the Ts themselves if the info has to get back to them #eltchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@vladkaslniecko Or adapt the context over the language. So, taking English speakers out to eat locally, for example. #ELTChat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@JoshSRound How do you do ind ones with so many classes? #eltchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@bcnpaul1 @englishraven 'perceived' is such a dangerous word sometimes #ELTchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
mubeenfk:
|
RT @JoshSRound: @Marisa_C @Shaunwilden also need to have a range of tutorials - at start of course, then with regular follow-ups to monitor goals #eltchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@bcnpaul1 : Different, definitely. It's the academic equivalent of stepping in the same river twice... #eltchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
@Shaunwilden Absolutely, I'm a firm believer in skipping exercises if they are irrelevant for my learners. #eltchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
First we worked on what they wanted out of it (needs analysis) then I brought them some books to look through #ELTchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
RT @englishraven: @BrunoELT @chucksandy I think that's a really important priority: balance (Ss and T working together on the needs and relevance). #ELTChat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
point is when we get bogged down with this or that syllabus we forget we're already responding to sts needs by doing it differently #eltchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
RT @Marisa_C: Have you ever asked your Ss to choose their coursebook? #ELTchat > I sometimes do for 1:1 students. Can`t do it for the school
|
|
12:25 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@yitzha_sarwono yeah i was happy to use that sort of influence over students to help them stand on their feet #ELTchat
|
|
12:25 pm
|
theminddock:
|
#eltchat Targets > Needs > EU Language Levels > Job application, CV > Self Assessment Grid http://ht.ly/4kCpM
|
|
12:26 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
RT @Marisa_C: Have you ever asked your Ss to choose their coursebook? I have done it and it works really well #ELTchat
|
|
12:26 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
Hello everyone! Just arrived, trying to catch up with #ELTChat :-)
|
|
12:26 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
RT @Marisa_C: Have you ever asked your Ss to choose their coursebook? I have done it and it works really well #ELTchat
|
|
12:26 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@Marisa_C I like that at least if they 'choose' the book they can't complain about ti :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:26 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@stopspanglish same river twice - i like that idea #eltchat
|
|
12:26 pm
|
Begabungs:
|
RT @cybraryman1: WedChat:#ClavEd #ELTchat #ntchat #ptchat #ecosys#PHDchat#edmusichat#SGAchat #web20chat #DistEd#smchat#yalitchat#FYCchat:http://bit.ly/9bCqR
|
|
12:26 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
@vladkaslniecko @azangolszekely #eltchat exactly - most teachers can't decide which/whether to use a coursebook
|
|
12:26 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@Shaunwilden My pronunciation was hilarious! Almost as much fun as my Tasmanian colleague "doing" the American pron class #eltchat
|
|
12:26 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
RT @Marisa_C: First we worked on what they wanted out of it (needs analysis) then I brought them some books to look through #ELTchat
|
|
12:26 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@Marisa_C Some weeks it's a bit of a drag but worth it. A class of 18 ss is full of 18 people with diff needs #ELTchat
|
|
12:26 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@waykatewit : I do 1-on-1 classes, so my case is a little different. But it's still time-consuming. #eltchat
|
|
12:26 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@Shaunwilden Funny how often I've let classes choose the coursebook, and then want to ditch it three weeks later! #ELTChat
|
|
12:26 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @yearinthelifeof: @Marisa_C Some weeks it's a bit of a drag but worth it. A class of 18 ss is full of 18 people with diff needs #ELTchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
RT @bcnpaul1: when we get bogged down w/ this- that syllabus we forget we're already responding to SS needs by doing it differently #eltchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@Shaunwilden Yes! The nice thing about it is that they usually choose better than some teachers I know :-D #eltchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@yearinthelifeof How many classes a week do you have with your students? I teach 13 different groups - wouldn't work for me! #ELTchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@Marisa_C i did it last year! they were really happy then :-)We had one session about different books...they made research, enjoyed #eltchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@chucksandy @azangolszekely the grammar syllabus will usually be relevant - I add other vocabulary and situations #ELTchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
mickstout:
|
@Marisa_C Never had chance 2 do that , but I've let sts choose content in project based classes. Works well, & makes it relevant. #ELTchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @sandymillin: @yearinthelifeof How many classes a week do you have with your students? I teach 13 different groups - wouldn't work for me! #ELTchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
@Marisa_C Don't use coursebooks, but often give learners a choice in topics/activities we do in class... find that works well, too #ELTChat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
I do. Bring is a selection and we browse. RT @Marisa_C: Have you ever asked your Ss to choose their coursebook? #ELTchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
@Shaunwilden @sandymillin Cover T does tutorials for ss on courses of 4 wks or more, thn updates info into registers. Cd work betta #eltchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@esolcourses @Marisa_C sounds interesting to give students such an opportunity - instead of coursebook wt dey wnt to learn #ELTchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@englishraven @vladkaslniecko I used to do that. Once when teaching clothes vocab I took them to a dep store w/ a shopping list #ELTChat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@JoshSRound : There's a good prelim questionnaire in CUP's "Learner Autonomy"; & ask abt short-, med- & long-term goals. #eltchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
RT @Marisa_C: Have you ever asked Ss to choose their coursebook? #ELTchat > yes, for 1:1 classes, but often they want teacher to decide
|
|
12:27 pm
|
yitzha_sarwono:
|
@Marisa_C Sadly we can't choose our own course book here in indonesia,there are certain curriculum to be followed #eltchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@grahamstanley i'd recommend NOT using a coursebook - it is immensely liberating & gives u freedom to work WITH students #eltchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@yearinthelifeof Ah, the one-paragraph essay #eltchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@JoshSRound Sounds like an interesting system though #eltchat
|
|
12:27 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
#ELTchat @stopspanglish yes - but I agree it's great if you can handle it
|
|
12:28 pm
|
theminddock:
|
#eltchat Targets > Needs > People Capability Maturity Model P-CMM http://ht.ly/4kCuP
|
|
12:28 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
RT@JoshSRound also need to have a range of tutorials - at start of course, then with regular follow-ups to monitor goals #eltchat Agreed!!
|
|
12:28 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@sandymillin I can imagine! Lucky to have time to develop relationships with learners #ELTchat
|
|
12:28 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
We can go further than textbook choice. Why not choice of what happens day to day - give Ss options. #eltchat
|
|
12:28 pm
|
mickstout:
|
@JoshSRound Great for mature sts in private classes. Not always gd 4 immature sts in school, or even uni #ELTchat
|
|
12:28 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @ddeubel: Sue Swift has an awesome presentation on needs anal. - http://bit.ly/gYmQC5 #ELTChat - Thx! =)
|
|
12:28 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
RT @AnneSinclair1: Do my business sts need me to know sth about business? #eltchat > Maybe their 1st task should be to explain some to you.
|
|
12:28 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
RT @englishraven: @Shaunwilden Funny how often I've let classes choose the coursebook, and then want to ditch it three weeks later! #ELTChat
|
|
12:28 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@bcnpaul1 think that depends on the teacher and their motivation. could be mechanical #eltchat
|
|
12:28 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
RT @bcnpaul1 i'd recommend NOT using a coursebook #eltchat > Yes, but it depends on how busy you are / how many classes you have
|
|
12:29 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
RT @ddeubel: We can go further than textbook choice. Why not choice of what happens day to day - give Ss options. #eltchat > If I could...
|
|
12:29 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
Will be out of reach for 10 mins - sorry everyone - technician here wants me off web #ELTchat
|
|
12:29 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@englishraven Exactly!though, there r some topics I do have 2 change >> space-I had group of 10 women >>not interested at all :-))) #eltchat
|
|
12:29 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
@sandymillin students really love it; wd like to do it for all students, but still working on how to :)) #eltchat
|
|
12:29 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
to be frank i'm a bit uncomfortable if i've nth to teach - i mean materials #ELTchat
|
|
12:29 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @grahamstanley: RT @bcnpaul1 i'd recommend NOT using a coursebook #eltchat > Yes, but schools might insist on it
|
|
12:29 pm
|
yitzha_sarwono:
|
RT @esolcourses: @Marisa_C Don't use coursebooks, but often give learners a choice in topics/activities we do in class... find that works well, too #ELTChat
|
|
12:29 pm
|
cybraryman1:
|
Have you together with your students developed your own coursebook over the course of a year? #eltchat
|
|
12:29 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @Marisa_C: Have you ever asked your Ss to choose their coursebook? #ELTchat - I whish we could do that here! =)
|
|
12:29 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
Question for all: What dictates the vocabulary you teach? Do you have some long-term goal? #ELTchat For me... viva AWL!
|
|
12:29 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@sandymillin you mean doing it differently each year? maybe - but those ppl shouldn't be teaching IMO :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:29 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@Shaunwilden @grahamstanley Another option is having Ss go through the coursebook and rank units in order of interest/relevance. #ELTChat
|
|
12:29 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
I dunno if this works with YLs, but w/adults - address fears about learning and failure. #eltchat
|
|
12:29 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@bcnpaul1 @grahamstanley some types of teachers do need a coursebook as scaffolding - just as the Ss #ELTchat
|
|
12:29 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@JoshSRound I always appreciate tutorials as a student- teacher taking time out for me. But seldom saw that applied in class #eltchat
|
|
12:29 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
I find Ss from a certain background ( years of being told what to do & how to learn) need to be trained in choice & autonomy #eltchat
|
|
12:30 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
RT @englishraven: @Shaunwilden @grahamstanley Another option is having Ss go through the coursebook and rank units in order of interest/relevance. #ELTChat
|
|
12:30 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
@mickstout true, depends on student 'investing' in the tutorial concept #eltchat
|
|
12:30 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@bcnpaul1 That's what I think too, but unfortunately there aren't enough of US to go around ;) and feel sorry for SS #eltchat
|
|
12:30 pm
|
tatisequeira:
|
RT @esolcourses: teachers are often put under pressure to get s's to pass exams, but syllabus may not be relevant to what learners want or need #ELTChat
|
|
12:30 pm
|
yitzha_sarwono:
|
@mickstout @Marisa_C yes,not possible to choose a book,but it is possible to choose our project though still based on the book #eltchat
|
|
12:30 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
RT @Marisa_C: @Shaunwilden Agree YL's not in a position to identify needs - that's why they need EXPERT Ts not the least qualified #ELTchat
|
|
12:30 pm
|
tatisequeira:
|
RT @esolcourses: Think delivering what learners need is ultimately down to teachers, but teachers rarely get full say in deciding what to teach #ELTChat
|
|
12:30 pm
|
oyajimbo:
|
#ELTchat let ss choose have done: works, as they respected the choice & asked for advice. Same with readers
|
|
12:30 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @cherrymp: to be frank i'ma bit uncomfortable if i've nth to teach-i mean materials #ELTchat@cherrymp man? (cont) http://deck.ly/~sJ5b6
|
|
12:30 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
@Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 #eltchat > I remember a no coursebook summer course we did and parents weren't happy either
|
|
12:30 pm
|
mickstout:
|
@esolcourses Different of course! You rflect on what yuo did and you add and subtract according to how it worked! #ELTchat
|
|
12:30 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
RT @englishraven: @Shaunwilden @grahamstanley Another option is having Ss go through the coursebook and rank units in order of interest/relevance. #ELTChat
|
|
12:30 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@stopspanglish esp in s east asia - face is a big concept -nb wnts to make mistakes #ELTchat
|
|
12:30 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: @Marisa_C I like that at least if they 'choose' the book they can't complain about ti :-) #eltchat - LOL! =)
|
|
12:30 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @englishraven: Another option is having Ss go through the coursebook and rank units in order of interest/relevance. #ELTChat gd idea
|
|
12:30 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
RT @waykatewit: @bcnpaul1 @grahamstanley some types of teachers do need a coursebook as scaffolding - just as the Ss.Yes it's true. #eltchat
|
|
12:31 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
RT @englishraven: @Shaunwilden @grahamstanley Another option is having Ss go thru CB and rank units in order of interest/relevance. #eltchat
|
|
12:31 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@shaunwilden schools insist on c'bk - true & a difficult one to get around - they bought it so they expect to use it, but... #eltchat
|
|
12:31 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@englishraven @Shaunwilden @grahamstanley Great - but what if the Ss's attitudes differ? (groups i mean) #ELTchat
|
|
12:31 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@Marisa_C Might be appreciated - but our SS go up a level a year. CB determined by what school ahs #ELTchat
|
|
12:31 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@cherrymp What makes you feel uncomfortable? #eltchat
|
|
12:31 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@englishraven @Shaunwilden @grahamstanley that's a good idea - a learning community where students too have a say #ELTchat
|
|
12:31 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
RT @englishraven: @Shaunwilden @grahamstanley ...Ss go ... rank units in order of interest/relevance. #ELTChat > this I like a lot
|
|
12:31 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@JoshSRound @mickstout True - one way traffic in a tutorial doesn't benefit you or the learner #ELTchat
|
|
12:31 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@waykatewit : Many of my adult learners stuck @ A2/B1 level have the same issues, so you can recycle a lot of material & ideas. #eltchat
|
|
12:31 pm
|
theminddock:
|
#eltchat Targets > Job application, CV > EU Language Passport http://ht.ly/4kCCw
|
|
12:31 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: @Marisa_C at least if they 'choose' the book they can't complain :-) #eltchat - They will still want ALL the pages!
|
|
12:31 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
@mickstout absolutely! Don't think I've ever taught a lesson that was identical to a previous one... always remix some elements #ELTchat
|
|
12:31 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@grahamstanley really? when was that? #eltchat
|
|
12:31 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
RT @sandymillin: @Marisa_C Might be appreciated - but our SS go up a level a year. CB determined by what school ahs #ELTchat > Same here
|
|
12:31 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
RT @yitzha_sarwono: yes,not possible to choose a book,but it is possible to choose our project though still based on the book #eltchat
|
|
12:32 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@waykatewit Make it a group vote on each unit. Patterns inevitably emerge. #ELTChat
|
|
12:32 pm
|
edumazing:
|
Brilliant RT @Marisa_C: Have you ever asked your Ss to choose their coursebook? I have done it and it works really well #ELTchat
|
|
12:32 pm
|
naminoro:
|
B/c it is eFl and "foreign" often means irrelevant b/c the L2 is not needed outside of school #eltchat
|
|
12:32 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@teacher_prix I explain / teach they why not all the pages are relevant and how its better to learn Eng than cover a book #eltchat
|
|
12:32 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
RT @englishraven: @waykatewit Make it a group vote on each unit. Patterns inevitably emerge. -- I do this too. #eltchat
|
|
12:32 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@cherrymp Very true, & many would sooner die than admit that they're afraid of something!! #eltchat
|
|
12:32 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@AnneSinclair1 Agreed... I usually do some research prior to first class, but ask St to explain it #eltchat
|
|
12:32 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@barbsaka wt to teach - i value my students' time and wonder whether i've sth to share with them if i don't have ath to take wid me #ELTchat
|
|
12:32 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@grahamstanley @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 I know that >>parents can be suspicious about paperless teaching #eltchat
|
|
12:32 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
#eltchat Groups - it's impossible to be wholly relevant to every student at all times, but needs analyses and follow ups keep us on track
|
|
12:32 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
#eltchat @cherrymp @englishraven @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 the most important thing is to include SS in the learning choices - > lrnr autonomy
|
|
12:33 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
How I developed an academic vocabulary syllabus based on ss long-term needs http://bit.ly/eh9fpZ #ELTchat
|
|
12:33 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@stopspanglish Agree! #ELTchat
|
|
12:33 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@chucksandy @waykatewit c'bk as scaffolding yes. c'bk as the main tool for course syllabus no #eltchat
|
|
12:33 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat @cherrymp @englishraven @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 the most important thing is to include SS in the learning choices - > lrnr autonomy
|
|
12:33 pm
|
mickstout:
|
@esolcourses Exactly! Actually, I want to repeat courses. I usually takes doing it 2 or 3 times to START getting it right. #ELTchat
|
|
12:33 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat the most important thing is to include SS in the learning choices - > lrnr autonomy > agree
|
|
12:33 pm
|
LiamDunphy:
|
?@cybraryman1: Have you together with your students developed your own coursebook over the course of a year? #eltchat? wikis 4 student books
|
|
12:34 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@edumazing @Marisa_C Did they all choose the same book? Could make for a hectic class if they'd all chosen diff books #ELTchat
|
|
12:34 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@vladkaslniecko @grahamstanley @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 Change from traditional usually not well received. #eltchat
|
|
12:34 pm
|
oyajimbo:
|
#ELTchat Biz classes particularly appreciate choice of CB. Client pays anyway
|
|
12:34 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@ddeubel Would be great to do that, but with bigger groups, exams to pass etc can be very difficult. Trying though! #eltchat
|
|
12:34 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@grahamstanley @chucksandy Yes, I agree. And Ss and groups always surprise me with their selections and rationales - every time! #ELTChat
|
|
12:34 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
i dn't stop with my students' ans - i ask them a follow up 'why' which many initially find it difficult - bt soon dey pick up #ELTchat
|
|
12:34 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
@bcnpaul1 @chucksandy @waykatewit How much guidance is given to (new) Ts on how best to 'use' a CB? interested if any? #eltchat
|
|
12:34 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @Marisa_C: @Shaunwilden Agree YL's not in a position to identify needs - that's why they need EXPERT Ts not the least qualified #ELTchat
|
|
12:34 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @CeciELT: @vladkaslniecko @grahamstanley @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 Change from traditional usually not well received. #eltchat
|
|
12:34 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@cherrymp : Avoiding fears/problems doesn't make them go away. Plus nobody's got v. WEIRD fears about English (I don't think...!) #eltchat
|
|
12:34 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@chucksandy @englishraven OK - that's a good idea. Anyway - what if you are aure the unpopulat topics should be studied ? :) #ELTchat
|
|
12:34 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@vladkaslniecko @grahamstanley @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 Today we have a PTA meeting coz parents don't accept our testless assessment #eltchat
|
|
12:34 pm
|
yitzha_sarwono:
|
@grahamstanley @cherrymp @englishraven @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 sound like a good idea to give them a chance to vote and autonomy #eltchat
|
|
12:35 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat @cherrymp @englishraven @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 the most important thing is to include SS in the learning choices - > lrnr autonomy
|
|
12:35 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @englishraven: @Shaunwilden @grahamstanley Another option is having Ss go through the coursebook and rank units in order of interest/relevance. #ELTChat
|
|
12:35 pm
|
mickstout:
|
@mubeenfk @mubeenfk At my uni we are finding that sts need to be taught HOW to be autonomous. and FORCED 2 b autonomous. Ironic ;-) #ELTchat
|
|
12:35 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
I did a prez called- deconstruct ur coursebook. 1st to cut it in pieces.The point: Ts have to make any coursebook their own. #eltchat
|
|
12:35 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@barbsaka Exactly - non-transferable skills are common in writing - you have to be a good writer to switch genres #ELTchat
|
|
12:35 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@CeciELT And do you think you'll convince them? #eltchat
|
|
12:35 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: RT @englishraven: Another option having Ss go through the cb rank units in order of interest/relevance. #ELTChat gd idea
|
|
12:35 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@vladkaslniecko @grahamstanley @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 True, and we have to respect that #ELTchat
|
|
12:35 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@CeciELT @grahamstanley @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 yes, it takes time >> happens also with adult classes (but satisfied then usually:)) #eltchat
|
|
12:35 pm
|
yitzha_sarwono:
|
RT @chucksandy: I did a prez called- deconstruct ur coursebook. 1st to cut it in pieces.The point: Ts have to make any coursebook their own. #eltchat
|
|
12:35 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@cherrymp So you use the coursebook as a syllabus--valid choice, I think. Many places, no book=not real class #eltchat
|
|
12:35 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@waykatewit In that case, perhaps T and Ss can take turns choosing what to look at next lesson. #ELTChat
|
|
12:36 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@joshsround interesting question. action research gps mainly here plus the wonders of staffroom /phtcopy room conversation #eltchat
|
|
12:36 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@chucksandy I agree SS need 'choice' training - difficult when only w/ them 90 mins a wk for 1 yr - then another TT! All change... #eltchat
|
|
12:36 pm
|
cybraryman1:
|
My Dogme page: http://bit.ly/dcmiig #eltchat
|
|
12:36 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@stopspanglish d prob is wen dey think of their prof in english getting equated wid deir intelligence and all #ELTchat
|
|
12:36 pm
|
JoBudden:
|
@waykatewit @bcnpaul1 @grahamstanley I agree! Course books give busy teachers a starting point. Can adapt materials for their ss. #ELTchat
|
|
12:36 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@cherrymp You have to do what works for you and your students #eltchat
|
|
12:36 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
@waykatewit: unpopular topics w/ useful language? Cover the same language w/ topics that are interesting & relevant. Just replace #eltchat
|
|
12:36 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
Hi. I've made it. Apologies for being late. Just catching up #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:36 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
@englishraven RT have Ss go through the coursebook and rank units in order of interest/relevance #ELTChat Good idea esp. for bus. english
|
|
12:36 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@englishraven @grahamstanley @chucksandy Surprise in a good way? #ELTchat
|
|
12:36 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
#ELTchat @CeciELT @vladkaslniecko @grahamstanley @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 so there should B 2 kinds of assessment - 4 parents + 4 SS?
|
|
12:36 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@cecielt good that yr having a meeting. maybe you can persuade them ;-) #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@Shaunwilden We're going to try! Show how assessment thru portfolios and no tests r more realistic and fair. Prob not convince all #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@barbsaka it's like an anchor - sth to test against - wt u thought and how rel or wtever - rather than talking in d air #ELTchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
@Shaunwilden: We have put a Ts and Parents meeting to explain not every page will be used, but the syllabus will be fully covered #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
The one thing I don't envy you Ts of YLs - having to do battle with the expectations of parents, rather than the kids themselves. #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
edumazing:
|
What about experiential learning? This is a very powerful way 2 teach languages without coursebooks #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
how come we always seem to end up talking about #dogme on #eltchat :-)
|
|
12:37 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@yearinthelifeof Students almost always surprise me in a good way. As a teacher, I love surprises!!! #ELTChat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@yitzha_sarwono @grahamstanley @cherrymp @englishraven @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 And motivating, too #ELTchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@bcnpaul1 @cecielt Doubt it (not that I'm happy to say it) #ELTchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
@sandymillin - oh, i don't know. I think one can nurture a lot of change in people w/ 90 mins a week for a year :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@waykatewit I def think it needs to be explained to parents at the beginning of a course #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@waykatewit @CeciELT @grahamstanley @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 not sure the result would be the same! what then?? #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@waykatewit lol! not a bad idea - i think communicating rationale is best. #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
RT @stopspanglish: The one thing I don't envy you Ts of YLs - having to do battle with the expectations of parents, rather than the kids themselves. #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
@bcnpaul1 often think Ts approach a CB thinking 'How best to do this page' rather than 'Why do this page?' #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
Id love to see that RT @chucksandy: I did a prez called- deconstruct ur coursebook. point: Ts make any coursebook their own. #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
@teacher_prix - I'll find it later. Univ. may have some ownership but I'll find a workaround to my curriculum dev. material. #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@waykatewit No.... Just one, but you have to stand up and stick to it til parents see the benefits #ELTchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@EclipsingX Welcome! Interesting chat tonight (as always!) #eltchat
|
|
12:37 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@chucksandy I do too! Just think it's sth we often forget...especially SS who've been studying for a while #eltchat
|
|
12:38 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
@waykatewit #eltchat teachers / schools do need to keep everyone happy
|
|
12:38 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @grahamstanley: how come we always seem to end up talking about #dogme on #eltchat :-) > I assure you, we don't (tho welcome!)
|
|
12:38 pm
|
yitzha_sarwono:
|
@waykatewit @grahamstanley @cherrymp @englishraven @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 hear hear! re:motivating #eltchat
|
|
12:38 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
RT @chucksandy: @waykatewit: unpopular topics w/ useful language? Cover the same language w/ topics that are interesting & relevant. Just replace #eltchat
|
|
12:38 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@yearinthelifeof @bcnpaul1 Sad to say I think you're right Adam... I hope the majority will believe and trust us though... #ELTchat
|
|
12:38 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: I explain / teach them y not all the pages are relevant and how its better to learn Eng than cover a book #eltchat
|
|
12:38 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@stopspanglish expectations are expectations whether they come from students or parents :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:38 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@Shaunwilden @waykatewit dey too are imp stakeholders - taking e'1 into confidence & communicating wid all of ur intentions helps #ELTchat
|
|
12:38 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
@CeciELT @vladkaslniecko @grahamstanley @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 that's really interesting and what happened? #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:38 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
RT @jobudden: Course books give busy teachers a starting point. adapt materials for their ss. #ELTchat > as long as materials ARE adapted
|
|
12:38 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @bcnpaul1: RT @jobudden: Course books give busy teachers a starting point. adapt materials for their ss. #ELTchat > as long as materials ARE adapted
|
|
12:39 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@barbsaka : Yeah, but the parents aren't the ones in the classroom. #eltchat
|
|
12:39 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@chucksandy @sandymillin OH definitely! You should see my adult classes...how they accepted my changes :-)) ...and seem to be happy #eltchat
|
|
12:39 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @grahamstanley: how come we always seem to end up talking about #dogme on #eltchat :-) - Funny!
|
|
12:39 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@EclipsingX I can tell you tomorrow.... meeting is in about 10 hours ;-) #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:39 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@vladkaslniecko @grahamstanley @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 Although coursebook-less doesn't necessarily = paperless #eltchat
|
|
12:39 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@englishraven @yearinthelifeof yeah sometimes i feel they're d real judges of teachers and wtever v do in class #ELTchat
|
|
12:39 pm
|
edumazing:
|
If every class we have is different , with different students, then why would we be using the same coursebooks? #eltchat
|
|
12:39 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@chucksandy I would say even in 60 minutes a week--that's all most of us have! #eltchat
|
|
12:39 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
RT @joshsround: often think Ts approach a CB thinking 'How best to do this page' rather than 'Why do this page?' #eltchat > how true!!
|
|
12:39 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@chucksandy - I mean, unpopular topics that should be taught - as 4 language - I do as you described #ELTchat
|
|
12:39 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @yearinthelifeof: How I developed an academic vocabulary syllabus based on ss long-term needs http://bit.ly/eh9fpZ #ELTchat
|
|
12:39 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @chucksandy: @sandymillin - oh, i don't know. I think one can nurture a lot of change in people w/ 90 mins a week for a year :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:39 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
@barbsaka TY for welcome @stopspanglish changing those expectations takes time and trust #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:39 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
RT @sandymillin: RT @Shaunwilden: I explain / teach them y not all the pages are relevant and how its better to learn Eng than cover a book #eltchat
|
|
12:39 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
RT @grahamstanley: @waykatewit #eltchat teachers / schools do need to keep everyone happy
|
|
12:40 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
#eltchat coursebooks are the fast food of ELT : attractively packaged, quick and easy to consume, and leaves you feeling full but guilty
|
|
12:40 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
RT @bcnpaul1: RT @joshsround: often think Ts approach a CB thinking 'How best to do this page' rather than 'Why do this page?' #eltchat > how true!!
|
|
12:40 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat coursebooks are the fast food of ELT : attractively packaged, quick and easy to consume, and leaves you feeling full but guilty
|
|
12:40 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat coursebooks are the fast food of ELT : attractively packaged, quick and easy to consume, and leaves you feeling full but guilty
|
|
12:40 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@bcnpaul1 @jobudden yeah v often to adapt means extra work - many places teachers don't have that luxury of time #ELTchat
|
|
12:40 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
RT @sandymillin: Although coursebook-less doesn't necessarily = paperless #eltchat > no. and it shouldn't IMO
|
|
12:40 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
@Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 @jobudden yes there is a danger if the foundation of the course is the book. It can hinder learning #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:40 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat coursebooks are the fast food of ELT : attractively packaged, quick and easy to consume, and leaves you feeling full but guilty
|
|
12:40 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
@vladkaslniecko I can just imagine ^^ And what i imagine is you're easy to follow. So much depends on a good rapport w/ Ss yes? #eltchat
|
|
12:40 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@JoshSRound A bit of guidance at my school, but with a syllabus with lots to cover think it can be forgotten. TT here are good tho! #eltchat
|
|
12:40 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@grahamstanley Beautifully said Graham... And then you go on a restrictive diet after binge-coursebooking? #eltchat
|
|
12:40 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
@mickstout agree, too. Something I always try to do B4 teaching unfamilar courses is shadow/observe others teaching it, first #ELTChat
|
|
12:40 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
RT @cherrymp: @Shaunwilden @waykatewit dey too are imp stakeholders - taking e'1 into confidence & communicating wid all of ur intentions helps #ELTchat
|
|
12:41 pm
|
edumazing:
|
@vladkaslniecko Parents will only be suspicious if we don't show them the value of alternatives #eltchat
|
|
12:41 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@CeciELT Many great learners fail to show their competencies in assessed situations #ELTchat
|
|
12:41 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@grahamstanley Hang on fast food, does that you'll be mentioning grammr mcnuggets next? :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:41 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat coursebooks are the fast food of ELT : attractively packaged, quick and easy to consume, and leaves you feeling full but guilty
|
|
12:41 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
@waykatewit - can you give some examples of unpopular topics that should be taught? #eltchat
|
|
12:41 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
RT @bcnpaul1: RT @jobudden: Course books give busy teachers a starting point. adapt materials for their ss. #ELTchat > as long as materials ARE adapted
|
|
12:41 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@bcnpaul1 @joshsround true - teaching as performance - how well to perform and get all the applause #ELTchat
|
|
12:41 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@barbsaka : We laugh about "stage moms" but there are also parents who force their kids to master Eng because the parents couldn't. #eltchat
|
|
12:41 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@CeciELT How are you going to present paperless assessment to the parents? #eltchat
|
|
12:41 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
@Shaunwilden @chucksandy @sandymillin I think it depends on the teacher and their attitude #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:41 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
RT @EclipsingX: @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 @jobudden ... danger if the foundation of the course is the book... #ELTCHAT > agree
|
|
12:41 pm
|
yitzha_sarwono:
|
@edumazing same coursebook? Here...for the sake of standard made by government -sigh- #eltchat
|
|
12:41 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@EclipsingX Agreed too many syllabi I've seen in schools are simply based on the cbk #eltchat
|
|
12:41 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
#ELTchat @bcnpaul1 @jobudden yes - DOS should oversee that, maybe...
|
|
12:42 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
@Shaunwilden I promise not to if you don't :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:42 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
guess i miss a lot - bt i guess #ELTchat is all about that - live time chat wid so many ppl - so many threads
|
|
12:42 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@CeciELT I think, once you (AND students) get to point where you don't need cbooks, it is VERY hard to go back! #ELTChat
|
|
12:42 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat cbs ar the fast food of ELT: attractively packaged, quick + easy to consume, + leaves u feeling full but guilty
|
|
12:42 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
RT @grahamstanley: RT @EclipsingX: @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 @jobudden ... danger if the foundation of the course is the book #ELTCHAT > agree
|
|
12:42 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@yearinthelifeof #ELTchat Completely agree Adam, and it's about what the test asks you, never about what you can produce naturally.
|
|
12:42 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@cherrymp you take what works for you, and try new things little by little #eltchat
|
|
12:42 pm
|
dreadnought001:
|
I think Ss (& parents) need the reassurance of a book, I prefer to create own material but with gd grammar book as reference for Ss #eltchat
|
|
12:42 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@barbsaka: ... but if I see a kid who can sing the "SpongeBob" theme in English, that gives me hope! #eltchat
|
|
12:42 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@grahamstanley I often felt nauseous after, too #ELTchat
|
|
12:42 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@yearinthelifeof Didn't all choose same but finally negotiated down to one title #ELTchat
|
|
12:42 pm
|
oyajimbo:
|
Not dogme: key point 4 my ss is the 'free' extras eg Cd-rom, website #ELTchat as 4 YL, educate patents key
|
|
12:42 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
RT @edumazing: If every class we have is different , with different students, then why would we be using the same coursebooks? #eltchat
|
|
12:42 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@grahamstanley nice thought - accountability - that's wt counts - how well i've spent mine and my students' time #ELTchat
|
|
12:43 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
RT @grahamstanley:coursebooks are the fast food of ELT:attractively packaged, quick to consume,leaves you feeling full but guilty #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:43 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@grahamstanley Great - I just compared Coursebooks 2 Mc Donalds' a few mins ago in this chat :)) #ELTchat
|
|
12:43 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
@chucksandy always try 2 show them there is a PURPOSE in change :-)) and collaboration w/ stds is so vital for classr. dynamics #eltchat
|
|
12:43 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
RT @teacher_prix: RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat cbs ar the fast food of ELT: attractively packaged, quick + easy to consume, + leaves u feeling full but guilty
|
|
12:43 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat coursebooks are the fast food of ELT : attractively packaged, quick and easy to consume, and leaves you feeling full but guilty
|
|
12:43 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@EclipsingX @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 @jobudden courseboos can be the starting point - bt v need to go beyond #ELTchat
|
|
12:43 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @JoshSRound: @bcnpaul1 often think Ts approach a CB thinking 'How best to do this page' rather than 'Why do this page?' #eltchat <agreed
|
|
12:43 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat c'bks are the fast food of ELT : attractively packaged, qk and easy to consume, and leaves you feeling full...
|
|
12:43 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat coursebooks are the fast food of ELT : attractively packaged, quick and easy to consume, and leaves you feeling full but guilty
|
|
12:43 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@sandymillin We're going to list the benefits, explain what a portfolio is, talk about ST responsibility and integrated skills.... #eltchat
|
|
12:43 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
@CeciELT @grahamstanley absolutely.) Maybe a harsh detox with the learners!!! #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:43 pm
|
edumazing:
|
@yearinthelifeof It works if u provide open-ended questions that are relevant 2 all books. Ss can also create own inquiry questions #eltchat
|
|
12:44 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
Why teaching formulaic writing doesn't meet long-term needs - good article http://www.jstor.org/stable/3588074 Baaddd 5 parag essay #ELTchat
|
|
12:44 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@esolcourses @mickstout that's an interesting thought - watching how others teach - obs in a non-threatening way #ELTchat
|
|
12:44 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
@barbsaka actually it's possible to nurture change in ppl w/ less than 60 mins/wk.Short regular/encouraging talks can do it. #eltchat
|
|
12:44 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@sandymillin And show some student portfolios so parents see their kids producing authentically, not just replying #eltchat
|
|
12:44 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@bcnpaul1 @grahamstanley Depends on the coursebook and how much leeway you've got to supplement.... #eltchat
|
|
12:44 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
@bcnpaul1 @sandymillin nice point #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:44 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@CeciELT Sounds perfect #eltchat
|
|
12:44 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@sandymillin @CeciELT If you can video SS before and after the term - parents R sure to see the difference - B satisfied #ELTchat
|
|
12:44 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @sandymillin: @CeciELT How are you going to present paperless assessment to the parents? #eltchat
|
|
12:44 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
Yes!RT @chucksandy: @barbsaka Possible to nurture change in ppl w/ less than 60 mins/wk.Short regular/encouraging talks can do it. #eltchat
|
|
12:44 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@grahamstanley @EclipsingX @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 @jobudden Any of you have goals in mind when teaching vocab? #ELTchat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
RT @stopspanglish: @barbsaka: ... but if I see a kid who can sing the "SpongeBob" theme in English, that gives me hope! Love it! #eltchat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
englishraven:
|
Getting back to main topic... 'global' coursebooks will struggle to meet the localised needs of your Ss. Ts need to add/adapt. #ELTChat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@englishraven Agreed Jason. The problem is getting some reluctant students to see that no CBs doesn't mean no direction / map! #ELTChat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: @EclipsingX Agreed too many syllabi I've seen in schools are simply based on the cbk #eltchat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@dreadnought001 yeah sth to take back with them and read and study #ELTchat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
maybe do/don't use c'bk is getting off the point. c'bks don't mean sts not involved - if using a c'bk we still need to involve sts #eltchat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@waykatewit That works really well, we use the videos at the end of year certificate presentation #eltchat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@englishraven I remember a certain Brazilian student you had... you know what I'm talking about ;-) #ELTChat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
can't blame tools for bad work #eltchat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
Agreed! RT @bcnpaul1: can't blame tools for bad work #eltchat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@sandymillin Fingers crossed here!!! :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@Marisa_C Great way of focusing on the learners. Did they reflect on their decisions at a later date? #ELTchat
|
|
12:45 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
@vladkaslniecko - Yes! Right on! always try 2 show them there is a PURPOSE in change :-)) #eltchat
|
|
12:46 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@barbsaka :) - teachers need to monitor wt works and wt won't in order to do that - responsibility doesnt end after class #ELTchat
|
|
12:46 pm
|
azangolszekely:
|
@englishraven or better still, create their own stuff with a local context #eltchat
|
|
12:46 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
@vladkaslniecko @chucksandy definately. Even if a few change at a time that starts to add up to a whole amount of change.) #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:46 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
RT @englishraven: Getting back to main topic... 'global' coursebooks will struggle to meet the localised needs of your Ss. Ts need to add/adapt. #ELTChat
|
|
12:46 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@chucksandy @waykatewit Think unpopular topics are an issue w/ teens whn you should teach thm about world too e.g. 'serious' topics #eltchat
|
|
12:46 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@CeciELT Ooh yeah. But in her defense, I hadn't perhaps given her fair enough warning about the how/why of my teaching :-) #ELTChat
|
|
12:46 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@waykatewit Agreed... but at the same time, maybe that would be exposing the students? #ELTchat
|
|
12:46 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
Sounds like lots of teachers are "stuck" with apparently irrelevant materials. How do you make them relevant? #eltchat
|
|
12:46 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@yearinthelifeof My goal would be teach what they want but make sure they get high surrender value vocab if it's Gen eng course #eltchat
|
|
12:46 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @barbsaka: Sounds like lots of teachers are "stuck" with apparently irrelevant materials. How do you make them relevant? #eltchat
|
|
12:46 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@yearinthelifeof Yes - they did - eventually said they liked it better when I wasn't using it but made them feel safe :-D #ELTchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@cherrymp That's what we all do :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
oyajimbo:
|
#ELTchat that's parents btw not patents!
|
|
12:47 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@azangolszekely Absolutely. Just bearing in mind that in many contexts there will be insistence on a global cbook upfront. #ELTChat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @barbsaka: @cherrymp you take what works for you, and try new things little by little #eltchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@yearinthelifeof @grahamstanley @EclipsingX @Shaunwilden @bcnpaul1 @jobudden> I do #ELTchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@yearinthelifeof which they also admitted was a bit silly :-D #ELTchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
@CeciELT #eltchat yes! And however much you tell yourself not to do so... it's always too tempting if you're busy
|
|
12:47 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
@Marisa_C Welcome back! Missed you :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: @yearinthelifeof My goal would be teach what they want but make sure they get high surrender value vocab if it's Gen eng course #eltchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
RT @Shaunwilden: @waykatewit That works really well, we use the videos at the end of year certificate presentation #eltchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
@grahamstanley: Sure, coursebooks are fast food to experienced teachers, but aren't they a good meal to many? Some Ts need them. #eltchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@yearinthelifeof I think vocab will primarily come with the topic and emergent needs of sts in communication #eltchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@bcnpaul1 true - bt many many workers won't agree - d buck has to stop s'where #ELTchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@barbsaka :-) luckily live 5 mins away from CELT #eltchat
|
|
12:47 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
RT @bcnpaul1: can't blame tools for bad work #eltchat
|
|
12:48 pm
|
mikecogh:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat coursebooks are the fast food of ELT : attractively packaged, quick and easy to consume, and leaves you feeling full but guilty
|
|
12:48 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@Marisa_C We all need safety blankets sometimes - perhaps coursebook publishers rely on this fact #ELTchat
|
|
12:48 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
Could we move away from CBs in the last quarter perhaps and talk about how to deal with our findings from NA? #ELTChat
|
|
12:48 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@barbsaka Good question... spinning them, bringing other materials, approaching from a different angle... dumping them (shhhhhh!) #eltchat
|
|
12:48 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @yearinthelifeof: @Marisa_C We all need safety blankets sometimes - perhaps coursebook publishers rely on this fact #ELTchat
|
|
12:48 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
I like the "Dog Whisperer" approach: Why are you here? How can I help you? What can I do that you can't do for yourself? #eltchat
|
|
12:48 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
@vladkaslniecko @englishraven very valid. There are things that don't translate across culture or interest or need #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:48 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@waykatewit Agreed - but what do you say to them during the term? ;) #ELTchat
|
|
12:48 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @Marisa_C: Could we move away from CBs in the last quarter perhaps and talk about how to deal with our findings from NA? #ELTChat
|
|
12:48 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
RT @Marisa_C: Could we move away from CBs in the last quarter perhaps and talk about how to deal with our findings from NA? #ELTChat
|
|
12:48 pm
|
azangolszekely:
|
with the publng tools put in our hands by the Internet it's never been easr to create good qulty mtrls or make use of authtic mtrls #eltchat
|
|
12:48 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
@JoBudden I agree - there's healthy fast food and then there's junk food ... btw not writing a coursebook by any chance are we :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:49 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
RT @barbsaka: teachers are "stuck" with apparently irrelevant materials. How do u make relevant? >> Teacher reflection important #eltchat
|
|
12:49 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@englishraven Do you think it would have changed her attitude. Coz I don't. Ppl are suspicious of "novelties"#ELTChat
|
|
12:49 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@bcnpaul1 I'm in an academic context and focus on the AWL. Any thoughts on genre-specific lists in long-term? #ELTchat
|
|
12:49 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@azangolszekely That sounds like a good response to my Q - so Ts as course writers #eltchat
|
|
12:49 pm
|
edumazing:
|
@yitzha_sarwono Thanks for the clarification of coursebook. I am referring 2 textbook :-) See how real & relevant can be different? #eltchat
|
|
12:49 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
The big problem I see w/coursebooks (including my own)are DOS who choose for Ts then say"teach this way according to this schedule. #eltchat
|
|
12:49 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@barbsaka personalisation wherever possible - sometimes forget tho as teaching lots of groups. depends on rapport w/ group #eltchat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@marisa_c are you slapping our wrists? :-) #eltchat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
...because what do you do when you've got a student who has this vague idea that he ought to learn Eng, but doesn't really need it? #eltchat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@CeciELT Rapport is so important. If that and trust aren't there at the start, all change/newness will be seen as threatening. #ELTChat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
JoBudden:
|
Thanks for the food for thought! Have to go to class. Really pleased I finally made it to #ELTchat! Bye for now.
|
|
12:50 pm
|
esolcourses:
|
@cherrymp @mickstout Yep. peer observation is the way it should be done, IMO. Too often the focus is on box-ticking rather than CPD #ELTChat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@stopspanglish wt's dis 'dog whisperer' approach??? #ELTchat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
RT @chucksandy: ...cbs are fast food to experienced teachers, but .. a good meal to many? Some Ts need them. #eltchat > Agree - I use 'em
|
|
12:50 pm
|
oyajimbo:
|
We've had same class 4 approx 15 yrs...h'wives. Make it up every Wk? #ELTchat think not, need skeleton at least
|
|
12:50 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
NNEST teachers also need a book to rely on for the correct languiage! @yearinthelifeof @Marisa_C #ELTchat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
RT @stopspanglish: I like the Dog Whisperer approach: Why are you here? How can I help you? ..... ^^ #eltchat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
CELT_Athens:
|
So we need to invite more school leaders to #ELTchat !!!! :-D @chucksandy #eltchat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
What do you do with student answers to your needs analysis? How do you meet their needs? #eltchat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @Marisa_C: Could we move away from CBs in the last quarter perhaps and talk about how to deal with our findings from NA? #ELTChat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
RT @CELT_Athens: So we need to invite more school leaders to #ELTchat !!!! :-D @chucksandy #eltchat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
@chucksandy yes and in several experiences in life this has been suffocating #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:50 pm
|
mubeenfk:
|
RT @grahamstanley: #eltchat coursebooks are the fast food of ELT : attractively packaged, quick and easy to consume, and leaves you feeling full but guilty
|
|
12:50 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@BrunoELT Needs Analysis = NA #ELTchat
|
|
12:50 pm
|
barbsaka:
|
RT @stopspanglish: I like the Dog Whisperer approach: Why are you here? How can I help you? #eltchat
|
|
12:51 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
RT @englishraven: @CeciELT Rapport is so important. If that and trust aren't there at the start, all change/newness will be seen as threatening. #ELTChat
|
|
12:51 pm
|
yitzha_sarwono:
|
RT @stopspanglish: I like the "Dog Whisperer" approach: Why are you here? How can I help you? What can I do that you can't do for yourself? #eltchat
|
|
12:51 pm
|
BrunoELT:
|
I see. Thanks! RT @Marisa_C: @BrunoELT Needs Analysis = NA #ELTchat
|
|
12:51 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@azangolszekely Agree - easy for those of us net-literate, but sooooo many teachers aren't #eltchat
|
|
12:51 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
RT @chucksandy: The big problem I see w/coursebooks (including my own)are DOS who choose for Ts then say"teach this way according to this schedule. #eltchat
|
|
12:51 pm
|
dreadnought001:
|
@chucksandy @grahamstanley yes, just finished running a CELTA course, the trainees need the c'bk crutch to get 'em through 1st job #eltchat
|
|
12:51 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
RT @JoshSRound: RT @barbsaka: Ts are "stuck" w/ apparently irrelevant materials. How do u make relevant? >> T reflection important #eltchat
|
|
12:51 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
RT @chucksandy: The big problem I see w/coursebooks (including my own)are DOS who choose for Ts then say"teach this way according to this schedule. #eltchat
|
|
12:51 pm
|
englishraven:
|
@barbsaka I see a lot of NAs and then just back to the usual approach/content. Ss might come to distrust NAs? #ELTChat
|
|
12:51 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
#ELTchat @chucksandy As a DOS I always collaborate with teachers on CB choice/schedule/syllabus
|
|
12:51 pm
|
grahamstanley:
|
@bcnpaul1 surely even you put your shoes on sometimes, Paul ? #eltchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @englishraven: @barbsaka I see a lot of NAs and then just back to the usual approach/content. Ss might come to distrust NAs? #ELTChat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
cherrymp:
|
@esolcourses @mickstout to win d confidence of those who're obs is sth that i find it difficult in #myanmar #ELTchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@yearinthelifeof eek -sorry but not sure what AWL is. could you tell me? #eltchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
edumazing:
|
Authentic assessment is the key 2 showing ss real potential 2 parents #eltchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
@englishraven @barbsaka Distrust or not fully understand their purpose #eltchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
worldteacher:
|
The longer you teach, the more personal resources you should have - during NA you should already be earmarking relevant materials #eltchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
JoshSRound:
|
RT @waykatewit: #ELTchat @chucksandy As a DOS I always collaborate with Ts on CB choice/schedule/syllabus > me too, consult Ts #eltchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
EclipsingX:
|
Needs Analysis are not only at the beginning but continue throughout the course. You change based on your learners needs. #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:52 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
RT @waykatewit: NNEST teachers also need a book to rely on for the correct languiage! @yearinthelifeof @Marisa_C #ELTchat > not all
|
|
12:52 pm
|
sandymillin:
|
@stopspanglish But when they do need it, can be hard to start. Met new adult SS w/ 0 English this wk - he needs it now bt no time #eltchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
waykatewit:
|
@Marisa_C @CELT_Athens @chucksandy Absolutely #ELTchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
vladkaslniecko:
|
RT @englishraven: @barbsaka I see a lot of NAs and then just back to the usual approach/content. Ss might come to distrust NAs? #ELTChat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
@grahamstanley - actually I don't use course books ^^I write them tho & try to put in the useful things I come up w in my classes. #eltchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@chucksandy +1!! #eltchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
ddeubel:
|
How many schools have a "good" curriculum developer on staff? Not many me thinks... #eltchat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
@englishraven Yes! SS hve 2 trust u & they'll know u have a gd reason 4 doing things. U dont question a pill a dr prescribes, do U? #ELTChat
|
|
12:52 pm
|
teacher_prix:
|
@BrunoELT Check it out: RT @ddeubel: Sue Swift has an awesome presentation on needs anal. - http://bit.ly/gYmQC5 #ELTChat
|
|
12:53 pm
|
dreadnought001:
|
@englishraven agreed, NA becomes a sop, the veneer of personalisation, many teachers do it and never act on it (myself included!) #eltchat
|
|
12:53 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
@grahamstanley shoes? shoes? er... well... I occasionally slip them on just to pop to McDonalds :) #eltchat
|
|
12:53 pm
|
chucksandy:
|
JoshSRound RT @waykatewit: well you're one of those good DOS ^^ #eltchat
|
|
12:53 pm
|
CeciELT:
|
RT @EclipsingX: Needs Analysis are not only at the beginning but continue throughout the course. You change based on your learners needs. #ELTCHAT
|
|
12:53 pm
|
edumazing:
|
@chucksandy I wouldn't just want recitals. I would want ss 2 share what it's about & their opinion as well #eltchat
|
|
12:53 pm
|
englishraven:
|
RT @dreadnought001: NA becomes a sop, the veneer of personalisation, many teachers do it and never act on it (myself included!) #eltchat
|
|
12:53 pm
|
yearinthelifeof:
|
@bcnpaul1 Academic Word List http://simple.wiktionary.org/wiki/Wiktionary:Academic_word_list You're lucky not to know! #ELTchat
|
|
12:53 pm
|
Shaunwilden:
|
RT @ddeubel: How many schools have a "good" curriculum developer on staff? Not many me thinks.#eltchat Probably not,it's a specialist skill
|
|
12:53 pm
|
Marisa_C:
|
@ddeubel Too few - most schools think syllabus=coursebook > never heard otherwise #eltchat
|
|
12:53 pm
|
stopspanglish:
|
@sandymillin : THAT's when it gets tough. Does he play any sports? Can you draw parallels btwn training and taking time to learn? #eltchat
|
|
12:53 pm
|
bcnpaul1:
|
RT @cecielt: SS hve 2 trust u & they'll know u have a gd reason 4 doing things. U dont question a pill a dr prescribes, do U? #ELTChat > |